Bonus Hallmark Mystery Movie Series With No Murders:
They solve mysteries of letters that can’t be delivered. I highly recommend this movie series!
Also, check out my other website Cozy Movie Cat
Above may be affiliate links and we earn commissions from qualifying purchases. Thank you very much for supporting our blog!
Do you know of any cozy mysteries without murder? Please leave a comment.
** This movie series is back Fall 2026 after a 6 year hiatus**
If you love finding a treasure at a garage sale and are a mystery lover then you will love The Garage Salem mystery movie series on Hallmark.
Jennifer Shannon owns a consignment shop, Rags To Riches, with her partner friend Dani. They go to garage sales, estate sales, and auctions to find treasures among the stuff. Jennifer just may stumble into a few mysteries in the process much to the chagrin of her husband Jason and her detective friend Frank. This one has an interesting premise and mysteries. Also, Jennifer is a wife and mother which you don’t often see in cozies. There are 16 movies in this series so there is a lot to explore. I highly recommend this series!
Above may be affiliate links and we earn commissions from qualifying purchases. Thank you very much for supporting our blog!
Are you going to watch the The Garage Sale Mysteries on Hallmark? Do you like going to garage sales? What is your best find at a garage sale? Please leave a comment.
Musician Gethsemane Brown goes to Ireland to teach music in a private school. The house she’s rented is haunted by a ghost Eamon that only she can see. He needs her help to solve his and his beloved’s murders. At the end, Gethsemane Brown is asked to help other ghosts cross over. This is a great movie series to watch in October for the light paranormal vibes. I haven’t read the book series. I prefer to watch a movie about music so I can hear rather than reading about music.
In this movie, Gethsemane and Eamon have a new murder to investigate that involves a ghost hunters filming crew. I don’t want to say too much about this movie so I don’t spoil it. I will just say that the mystery is fantastic and the reveal is shocking. I highly recommend this movie and series!
Above may be affiliate links and we earn commissions from qualifying purchases. Thank you very much for supporting our blog!
Have you read the Gethsemane Brown book series? Have you seen the Gethsemane Brown movies on Hallmark? What is your musical instrument to hear or play? Piano – I love listening to relaxing piano music. Please leave a comment.
The “Justice Warriors” (a group of Law students) are back to right wrongs in the justice system. This case takes place in the Winter so you may want to save it for the cold weather months. The case is intriguing and complex and the reveal is very satisfying. This movie is done in an interesting storytelling style which I really enjoyed and is worth watching for that alone. Also, there is some follow up from the first movie that I really appreciated. I highly recommend this movie!
Above may be affiliate links and we earn commissions from qualifying purchases. Thank you very much for supporting our blog!
Have you seen the True Justice movies on Hallmark? Are you going to watch the True Justice movies on Hallmark? Please leave a comment.
In this movie, Hannah gets involved with two mysteries. There are some interesting new elements in this movie not just the two mysteries but also you get to see Dolores as a PI, Chad in the courtroom, and Hannah get involved in ways that are different than all of the other movies. Chad secret gets revealed to Hannah in this one. Also, there is lots of cat action too. Moisha is in this one a lot. Plus, count how many cat tops Hannah wears in this one. This movie is not to be missed!
I recommend this movie just make sure you have a Chocolate Cheesecake and coffee when watching! Based on the book Triple Chocolate Cheesecake Murder by Joanne Fluke.
Above may be affiliate links and we earn commissions from qualifying purchases. Thank you very much for supporting our blog!
Have you read the Joanne Fluke book series? Have you seen the Hannah Swensen movies on Hallmark? Please leave a comment.
Also, check out my other website Cozy Movie Cat
If you love mysteries and When Calls The Heart than this one is for you!
This is a fun closed door mystery at a dinner party full of people aka suspects. Our main character Advice Columnist Nelly and Detective are in attendance as well. This mystery had twists, turns, and many secrets. Everybody looked guilty. I figured out part of the reveal but not all of it. Plus, there is an adorable dog in it. I highly recommend this movie and series!
Above may be affiliate links and we earn commissions from qualifying purchases. Thank you very much for supporting our blog!
Have you seen the Nelly Knows Mysteries movies on Hallmark? Please leave a comment.
Also, check out my other website Cozy Movie Cat
In this movie, Hannah and the Cookie Jar are catering dessert cookies and coffee for a costume party at the local hotel. It’s a fun mystery and it takes place partly on a stormy night which adds to the mystery. I did end up figuring it out before Hannah but it was still fun to watch Hannah and Co go through the evidence. Dolores was great in this one as always. I recommend this movie just make sure you have sugar cookie and coffee when watching! Based on the book Sugar Cookie Murder by Joanne Fluke.
Above may be affiliate links and we earn commissions from qualifying purchases. Thank you very much for supporting our blog!
Have you read the Joanne Fluke book series? Have you seen the Hannah Swensen movies on Hallmark? Please leave a comment.
Also, check out my other website Cozy Movie Cat
Mistletoe Murders
Emily is new in a small town and opened a year round Christmas shop. She has two cats and is well liked in the community so she seemingly has an idyllic life except she has an intriguing past that kept me coming back for more. Season 1 and Season 2 end with a cliffhanger. It hasn’t been renewed for Season 3 by Hallmark yet so keep that in mind before watching. I personally think it’s worth a watch despite the Season 2 cliffhanger that we may never get answers for.
This is an original series on Hallmark+ which you can get on Hoopla BingePass (one credit for 7 days of unlimited watching). Each mystery is 2 episodes long and there are 12 episodes (6 mysteries). The mysteries are great and very cozy but with some suspense thrown in. Anyone that loves cozy mystery books and Christmas would love this series. I haven’t listened to the Audible Original audiobook series so I can’t speak for that if it’s the same or not.
Five Gold Rings
This mystery is sweet and heartwarming. Audrey’s grandmother passes away and leaves her with a her final mission. To find the owners of five gold rings she found before Christmas, a tradition that Audrey’s grandmother had over the years. With the help of a PI Finn, Audrey find the owners of each of the five gold rings and all of the heartwarming stories that come with it. This one is a Christmas mystery that is sure to get you in the Christmas spirit.
Mystery on Mistletoe Lane
Heidi take a new job as the town historian in New Hollow uprooting her kids and embarking on a new journey…and mystery. This is a wholesome mystery of historical proportions both in the town and in Mistletoe Manor. This mystery is sure to get you in the Christmas spirit and touch your heart.
The Christmas Quest
For those looking for an international Christmas mystery this is for you! An archeologist and her ex husband that is a Norse expert go on a Christmas quest in Iceland to find hidden treasure. This one has some suspense and twists and turns in it making it great holiday fun with a meaningful lesson in it.
Hallmark Movie – Hallmark+ available on Hoopla BingePass
Above may be affiliate links and we earn commissions from qualifying purchases. Thank you very much for supporting our blog!
Looking for Christmas gifts for a cozy mystery lover, check out my Cozy Mystery Gifts page for ideas!
Have you seen any of these Hallmark Christmas Mystery movies? What is your favorite Hallmark Christmas Mystery movie? What is your favorite Christmas movie? Mine is It’s A Wonderful Life. Please leave a comment.
Musician Gethsemane Brown goes to Ireland to teach music in a private school. The house she’s rented is haunted by a ghost Eamon that only she can see. He needs her help to solve his and his beloved’s murders. At the end, Gethsemane Brown is asked to help other ghosts cross over. This is a great movie series to watch in October for the light paranormal vibes. I haven’t read the book series. I prefer to watch a movie about music so I can hear rather than reading about music.
In this movie, Gethsemane’s brother comes to visit and finds a body. It’s up to Gethsemane with the help of a few ghosts to solve the case. I love the Irish setting and this one has a sea feel to it. Gethsemane and the ghosts make this a fun and unique movie series perfect for the Fall season.
Above may be affiliate links and we earn commissions from qualifying purchases. Thank you very much for supporting our blog!
Have you read the Gethsemane Brown book series? Have you seen the Gethsemane Brown movies on Hallmark? What is your musical instrument to hear or play? Piano – I love listening to relaxing piano music. Please leave a comment.
This movie series is based on a book series but not a tradition cozy mystery series. I loved these movies so much I wanted to share them with you. They are very reminiscent of a cozy mystery. They have a mystery that involves a historical timeline, a present timeline, and a surprising timeline. All of the timelines weave together to solve the mystery. The mystery is wonderful and so is the romance and the premise. I highly recommend this movie series and want to read the book series!
Above may be affiliate links and we earn commissions from qualifying purchases. Thank you very much for supporting our blog!
Have you seen the Providence Falls movies on Hallmark? Are you going to watch the Providence Falls movies on Hallmark? Have you read the Providence Falls book series? Do you believe in soulmates? Please leave a comment.
Cozy Mystery Cat 